huntress logo

MDR vs SIEM: Which Cybersecurity Solution is Right for Your Business?

Key Takeaways:


  • MDR vs SIEM isn’t either/or. Start with MDR for faster deployment and better initial value, then layer in SIEM as you grow.

  • MDR delivers hands-on response and lower total cost of ownership, while SIEM provides deep visibility, compliance, and historical forensics.

  • Huntress offers a unified approach, letting you combine managed EDR and SIEM for enterprise-grade protection without the headaches.




At first glance, it might seem like you have to choose between MDR vs SIEM, but that’s the wrong approach. The real challenge is knowing where to start, what each one offers, and how they fit together in your cybersecurity journey. Let’s break it down step by step.

Topics
Share

MDR vs SIEM: Which Cybersecurity Solution is Right for Your Business?

Key Takeaways:


  • MDR vs SIEM isn’t either/or. Start with MDR for faster deployment and better initial value, then layer in SIEM as you grow.

  • MDR delivers hands-on response and lower total cost of ownership, while SIEM provides deep visibility, compliance, and historical forensics.

  • Huntress offers a unified approach, letting you combine managed EDR and SIEM for enterprise-grade protection without the headaches.




At first glance, it might seem like you have to choose between MDR vs SIEM, but that’s the wrong approach. The real challenge is knowing where to start, what each one offers, and how they fit together in your cybersecurity journey. Let’s break it down step by step.

What is MDR vs SIEM vs EDR?

MDR

MDR stands for managed detection and response. It seeks out and deals with cyberattacks and similar problems on your systems, essentially working as “detection and response as a service.” MDR combines endpoint detection and response (EDR) technology with a broader scope and human expertise. 

Compared to SIEM, MDR focuses on hands-on response and deep visibility at the endpoint level, where most attacks begin. SIEM, on the other hand, offers enterprise-wide visibility, compliance reporting, and historical log analysis. The total cost of ownership of an MDR solution is typically lower than that of SIEM, which is why many organizations choose MDR as their first investment, then layer SIEM on top as their needs grow. 

EDR

EDR is known as endpoint detection and response. EDR solutions monitor your end users' devices to protect and deal with cyber threats. It keeps a close eye on the activity of your organization's servers, terminals, laptops, and mobile devices, no matter where they are at the time.

EDR is narrower in scope than MDR. While EDR only focuses on endpoint devices, MDR builds on EDR by adding expert monitoring, broader detection, and active response across your environment. 

SIEM

SIEM (security information and event management) solutions log data from all over your IT environment and use that to sniff out the anomalies that give away vulnerabilities and cyber threats. It also spots latency issues, provides compliance reporting, and keeps a detailed historical log of all data traffic for forensic review. 

If MDR is detection and response as a service, SIEM is a data lake with compliance reporting that also enables broader visibility. SIEM is often more cost-effective for larger businesses, but it dovetails nicely with an existing MDR setup. To sum up, you can almost always add a SIEM solution to MDR.



Are MDR and SOC the same thing?

No. MDR is a solution, and a security operations center (SOC) is a team. MDR improves your security posture. It spots and tackles cyber threats. A SOC is a team of security specialists who monitor cybersecurity for your organization. They may oversee your MDR solutions, but they do much more.


Is MDR the same as managed EDR?

MDR is closely related to managed EDR, but they’re not the same. A managed EDR solution is the foundation, focusing on protecting your endpoints by detecting and responding to suspicious activity on those systems. 

MDR builds on managed EDR by adding broader visibility, advanced detection, and human-led response across your environment. With MDR, you get everything managed EDR provides, plus expert monitoring and rapid action to contain threats before they spread.  

Quick Summary: MDR vs Managed EDR

Managed EDR: Endpoint-focused security—monitoring, detecting, and responding to threats on devices like laptops, desktops, and servers.

MDR: Includes managed EDR but extends beyond, offering broader detection and response across your environment, backed by expert human analysis and support.


Which do you need? Both. Both are good.

MDR vs SIEM is not really an either/or question. The issue is really where to start based on budget and value. Compare the total cost of ownership, including licensing, staffing, and tuning. MDR is less expensive but much more limited. If your organization is small enough for the hands-on response aspects of MDR to suffice and is lucky enough not to have data compliance headaches, MDR is probably enough for the moment. 

The MDR vs SIEM decision is an organizational maturity journey, not a binary choice. Starting with MDR is often simply easier for organizations just getting started with this level of security. That being said, an integration pathway is clear when you need to add better visibility and compliance features to your security setup.

So, the answer is both.


Huntress is built for where you’re at

At Huntress, we don’t think of MDR as a starting point. It’s a complete, all-encompassing solution. By combining managed EDR, SIEM, and 24/7 human expertise, MDR delivers both the visibility and the response capabilities organizations need to stop threats in their tracks. 

For many businesses, MDR is generally the smarter first investment because it consolidates key functions that would otherwise require multiple tools and dedicated staff. Instead of juggling licensing, staffing, and turning across separate platforms, Huntress MDR brings it all together with: 

  • Simplified Licensing: Predictable pricing without hidden costs.

  • Reduced Staffing Needs: Our 24/7 SOC handles monitoring and response.

  • Less Complexity: A turnkey solution that integrates EDR, SIEM, and oversight.

The result is an MDR platform that scales with your business, whether you’re starting small or already operating at enterprise scale.



Huntress gives you layered security, without the headaches

Huntress lets you combine Managed EDR and Managed SIEM. You can choose one or layer both as your needs grow. 

Our managed EDR and SIEM offerings are designed to work seamlessly together, reinforcing each other to protect your business. We make enterprise-grade security solutions available to businesses of any size. By integrating EDR, SIEM, and other services like a 24/7 SOC, we give you an unmatched defense against cyber threats. Imagine the peace of mind you would get from a comprehensive, unified security strategy, as well as a predictable, no-nonsense pricing model.

Start your free trial or schedule a demo and see for yourself how Huntress can protect your business.




Protect What Matters

Secure endpoints, email, and employees with the power of our 24/7 SOC. Try Huntress for free and deploy in minutes to start fighting threats.
Try Huntress for Free